Subaru Cars for Sale Near Elma, NY

1 of 41

2020 subaru crosstrekPremium

$20,174$371.08/month est.

---

83,182

Upstate Chevrolet (18 miles away)

Message Dealer

2019 subaru ascentPremium

$16,995$312.61/month est.

---

83,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2019 subaru ascentUnknown

$15,995$294.21/month est.

---

106,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2018 subaru outback2.5i Premium

$14,995$275.82/month est.

---

115,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2019 subaru outback2.5i Limited

$15,995$294.21/month est.

---

116,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2016 subaru outback2.5i Limited

$13,995$257.42/month est.

---

93,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2024 subaru crosstrekSport

$25,995$478.15/month est.

---

42,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2019 subaru impreza2.0i

$16,995$312.61/month est.

---

27,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2017 subaru outback2.5i Premium

$15,995$294.21/month est.

---

49,000

White Horse Automotive (48 miles away)

Message Dealer

2024 subaru crosstrekWilderness

$31,277$575.31/month est.

---

12,767

Towne Mazda (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

2024 subaru crosstrekPremium

$26,249$482.82/month est.

---

23,336

Towne Mazda (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

2022 subaru outbackLimited XT

$26,970$496.09/month est.

---

31,387

Bidleman Chevrolet GMC (35 miles away)

Message Dealer

1 of 10

2018 subaru crosstrek2.0i Premium

$16,695$307.09/month est.

---

98,736

Certified Autobrokers (20 miles away)

Message Dealer

1 of 36

2025 subaru ascentOnyx Edition 7-Passenger

$35,457$652.19/month est.

---

13,412

Ray Laks Honda of Orchard Park (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

1 of 36

2025 subaru foresterSport Hybrid

$35,504$653.06/month est.

---

15,713

Ray Laks Honda of Orchard Park (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

1 of 35

2023 subaru foresterBase

$24,569$451.92/month est.

---

23,402

Ray Laks Honda of Orchard Park (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

1 of 35

2024 subaru imprezaBase 5-Door

$23,512$432.48/month est.

---

12,193

Ray Laks Honda of Orchard Park (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

1 of 36

2019 subaru foresterPremium

$18,726$344.45/month est.

---

83,934

Ray Laks Honda of Orchard Park (7 miles away)

Message Dealer

2024 subaru crosstrekLimited

$25,499$469.03/month est.

---

46,509

Maguire Toyota of Grand Island (21 miles away)

Message Dealer

2019 subaru crosstrek2.0i Limited

$17,999$331.07/month est.

---

66,445

Maguire Toyota of Grand Island (21 miles away)

Message Dealer

2025 subaru foresterLimited

$31,999$588.59/month est.

---

31,328

Maguire Toyota of Grand Island (21 miles away)

Message Dealer

2023 subaru crosstrekLimited

$26,999$496.62/month est.

---

22,890

Maguire Toyota of Grand Island (21 miles away)

Message Dealer

2019 subaru wrxPremium

$20,999$386.25/month est.

---

75,578

Maguire Toyota of Grand Island (21 miles away)

Message Dealer

---

Vehicle History Reports

Learn more about a vehicle you plan to buy to help avoid any hidden surprises.

Get Report

---

How We Calculate Price Badges

Our price badges compare a vehicle’s listed price with similar vehicles in your area using factors such as make, model, year, trim, body type, drivetrain, and whether the vehicle is new or used. The listed price is then compared against a benchmark price to assign the applicable badge. Badges are updated periodically, but may not reflect real-time market conditions. Price badges are provided for general informational purposes only and are based on available market data and statistical analysis. They do not constitute guarantees or representations of savings, fair value, resale value, or the final transaction price. Actual purchase prices may vary due to dealer fees, add-ons, financing terms, taxes, and other factors outside our control. Consumers should use this information as one of multiple considerations when evaluating a vehicle purchase.